Dominion and Liberty

OUR Laws make a distinction between Vassalage and Obedience; between a devouring Prerogative, and a licentious ungovernable Freedom: and as of all the Orders of Building, the Composite is the best, so ours by a happy mixture and a wise choice of what is best in others, is brought into a Form that is our Felicity who live under it, and the envy of our Neighbour that cannot imitate it.

The Crown hath power sufficient to protect our Liberties. The People have so much Liberty as is necessary to make them useful to the Crown.* Our Government is in a just proportion, no Tympany,* no unnatural swelling either of Power or Liberty; and whereas in all overgrown Monarchies, Reason, Learning, and Enquiry are hang’d in Effigy for Mutineers;* here they are encouraged and cherished as the surest Friends to a Government establish’d upon the Foundation of Law and Justice.

From ‘The Complete Works of George Savile, First Marquess of Halifax’ (1912). The original spelling has been retained. The Character of a Trimmer was begun in 1685, but not published until 1688.

* Depriving a people of their liberties does not make the public more serviceable to the State, but enervates and weakens them until the State itself cannot function. See John Stuart Mill on Losing Steam.

* In the medical sense of tympanites (tim-pan-eye-tees), a gaseous swelling of the abdomen, or in the sense of bombastic drum-beating on orchestral timpani, or quite possibly in both senses.

* That is, wherever Government power is too great, science and the arts are regarded as dangerous to the State, and carefully domesticated, censored or persecuted.

Précis
Halifax went on to compare state-building with architecture, saying that in both cases one should blend the best styles rather than be stubbornly purist. One may see that all things are in balance, he said, when the arts and sciences are trusted with liberty; for where there is tyranny, they are sure to be kept on a short leash.
Questions for Critics

1. What is the author aiming to achieve in writing this?

2. Note any words, devices or turns of phrase that strike you. How do they help the author communicate his ideas more effectively?

3. What impression does this passage make on you? How might you put that impression into words?

Based on The English Critic (1939) by NL Clay, drawing on The New Criticism: A Lecture Delivered at Columbia University, March 9, 1910, by J. E. Spingarn, Professor of Comparative Literature in Columbia University, USA.

Read Next

Traveller’s Check

A much-travelled Spanish visitor amazes an English audience with his tales of wonder overseas, until he is brought up short by his servant.

Wait and See

Edmund Burke would not congratulate the French revolutionaries on their ‘liberty’ until he knew what they would do with it.

Guardian of Peace

J. S. Mill argues that free trade has done more to put an end to war than any political union or military alliance.