The Best Laid Plans

Louis XIV died on September 8, 1715, at the age of seventy-seven, after a reign of seventy-two years. He left France utterly exhausted. The state was ruined and there seemed to be no resource but bankruptcy. Before the War of the Spanish Succession* [1702-1713] Vauban* had written, “Almost a tenth of the population is reduced to beggary; of the other nine-tenths, five cannot aid the tenth, being in a similar position; three-tenths are ill at ease; the remaining tenth, containing not more than 100,000 families, has only 10,000 who are comfortably off.”

The condition of affairs was worse in 1715 after a war during which money had been borrowed at 400 per cent., new taxes had been created, the revenue spent two years in advance, and the national debt increased to 2400 million francs.*

abridged

Abridged from ‘A Short History of France’ Vol. II (1917 edition) by Victor Duruy (1811-1894), translated by Lucy Menzies. Additional information from ‘Makers Of Modern Strategy’ (1948) by Edward Mead Earle (1894-1954); ‘France and the Failure to Modernize Macroeconomic Institutions’ (1999) by Eugene White; UK Parliament Research Briefings: The Public Finances: A Historical Overview (2018); and ‘Office for National Statistics: UK Government Debt and Deficit: March 2022’.

* See The War of the Spanish Succession.

* Sébastien Le Prestre de Vauban (1633-1707), Marquis de Vauban, was a French military engineer, widely regarded as one of the great engineers of European history. His contemporaries held him in the highest esteem. American historian Henry Edward Guerlac (1910-1985) wrote of him: “With his modest origin, his diligence and honesty, his personal courage, and his loyalty to the state, he seemed the reincarnation of some servitor of the Roman Republic. Indeed, Fontenelle, in his famous éloge, describes him as a ‘Roman, whom the century of Louis XIV seems almost to have stolen from the happiest days of the Republic.’ To Voltaire he was ‘the finest of citizens.’ Saint- Simon, not content with dubbing him a Roman, applied to him, for the first time with its modern meaning, the word patriote.”

* That is, 2.4bn francs or, as they were called at the time, livres. Modern scholars tend to prefer a slightly lower figure. In 1999, economist Eugene White calculated the debt at 1.8bn livres, with France’s nominal Gross National Product standing at 1.76bn. According to White, 1.76bn livres were worth about £116m at the time. Research in 2018 by the UK Parliament’s statisticians put Great Britain’s debt at £50m in 1715, or 60% of Gross Domestic Product, which is about £8.3bn in today’s money. The UK’s national debt in March 2022 stood at £2,365.4bn, or 99.6% of GDP.

Précis
Victor Duruy contrasted Louis’s bright hopes at the beginning of his reign with the reality towards its close. France, as described by contemporary engineer Sebastien Vauban, was bankrupt: most of the people were in abject poverty, and few could help their neighbours. And since Vauban’s time, Louis’s war debts had consumed revenues formerly pledged to the relief of the poor.
Questions for Critics

1. What is the author aiming to achieve in writing this?

2. Note any words, devices or turns of phrase that strike you. How do they help the author communicate his ideas more effectively?

3. What impression does this passage make on you? How might you put that impression into words?

Based on The English Critic (1939) by NL Clay, drawing on The New Criticism: A Lecture Delivered at Columbia University, March 9, 1910, by J. E. Spingarn, Professor of Comparative Literature in Columbia University, USA.

Read Next

An Englishman in Exile

Faced with a choice between silence, dungeon or exile, William Cobbett chose exile — and then had to make sense of it.

Candlemas

A February celebration for which the faithful have brought candles to church since Anglo-Saxon times.

Asylum Christi

Samuel Smiles explains how Tudor England was transformed from sleepy backwater to hive of industry.