Ministerial Myopia
We all want our politicians to be clever men, but being cunning isn’t the same as being wise.
1738
King George II 1727-1760
We all want our politicians to be clever men, but being cunning isn’t the same as being wise.
1738
King George II 1727-1760
Henry St John, 1st Viscount Bolingbroke, declared himself one of the Country Party, a loose and cross-bench federation of MPs speaking up (so they said) for the country as a whole, and not only for the elite only. In 1738, he wrote The Idea of a Patriot King for the benefit of Frederick, Prince of Wales, in which Bolingbroke distinguished between two kinds of politician.
There is, however, one distinction to be made as to the capacity of ministers, on which I will insist a little: because I think it very important at all times, particularly so at this time; and because it escapes observation most commonly. The distinction I mean is that between a cunning man and a wise man.* [...]
We may observe much the same difference between wisdom and cunning, both as to the objects they propose and to the means they employ, as we observe between the visual powers of different men. One sees distinctly the objects that are near to him, their immediate relations, and their direct tendencies: and a sight like this serves well enough the purpose of those who concern themselves no further. The cunning minister is one of those: he neither sees, nor is concerned to see, any further than his personal interests, and the support of his administration, require. If such a man overcomes any actual difficulty, avoids any immediate distress, or, without doing either of these effectually, gains a little time, by all the low artifice which cunning is ready to suggest and baseness of mind to employ, he triumphs, and is flattered by his mercenary train, on the great event; which amounts often to no more than this, that he got into distress by one series of faults, and out of it by another.
* Seer also William Cullen Bryant on Statesman vs Politician.
Suggest answers to this question. See if you can limit one answer to exactly seven words.
What, according to Bolingbroke, marks out the cunning minister?
A short-sighted preoccupation with his own career.
Express the ideas below in a single sentence, using different words as much as possible. Do not be satisfied with the first answer you think of; think of several, and choose the best.
He is short-sighted. He will not achieve anything.
See if you can include one or more of these words in your answer.
IAhead. IIFail. IIIUnless.